This is presented in this movie in a series of discussion between Homer and Larch.
Outline the arguments for or against abortion as presented in The Cider House Rules.
Who wins the argument at the end of the novel? The central message of the novel is that anti-abortion laws are unjust and unreasonable, as they lead to the death of women who, regardless of the law, will seek to end their pregnancies by any possible means.
Women are poisoned, pierced by crochet needles, their uteruses subjected to electric shock or suctioned out violently. He sees women die of botched abortions, and comes to the conclusion that he must help them. As Larch writes to the Roosevelts, he believes that in a democratic society, people must have the right to choose whether or not to bring a child into the world.
Since the law does not allow it, he breaks the law in order to offer women a choice. Therefore, abortion to him does not mean Cider house rules essay a life, but ending the potential for life. He thinks that a fetus has a soul.
He feels it is his right to choose whether to perform them or not. Larch wins the argument at the end of the novel, when Homer returns to St.
Homer never does change his mind regarding whether or not a fetus has a soul, but he accepts that as long as women have no choice, he has no choice, either. Since he knows how to perform abortions safely, he is morally obligated to help women who cannot otherwise procure one.
Throughout much of the novel, Dr. Larch attempts to lure Homer back to St. What finally bring Homer Wells back to St. Three events combine to bring Homer back to St. First, Melony appears at Ocean View Orchards. Her assessment of him—that he is living a cowardly life of lies—forces him to see that it is time for a change.
While Homer is in that frame of mind, he learns of the unwanted pregnancy of Rose Rose. Clearly, this is a girl who should not be having a child. Still, he at first is reluctant to take responsibility on himself. Even though he knows how to perform abortions, he does not wish to. Homer plans to send the girl to Dr.
Larch gone, the responsibility falls on Homer. He performs the abortion for Rose Rose. He returns to St. How does he succeed in becoming the hero of his own life, and what does that mean? The Cider House Rules may be described as a coming-of-age story in the tradition of nineteenth-century tales like David Copperfield and Oliver Twist.
Coming-of-age tales follow a main character from childhood to adulthood, throughout his or her moral education, until the hero finds his or her place in life.
The true hero of a story is one who acts, who takes decisive action to determine his or her fate. Part of growing up and becoming an autonomous adult means making decisions for oneself.
Larch wants Homer Wells to follow in his footsteps as a doctor, but he knows that Homer must see the world first, and learn more about himself, before he can really choose who he wants to be and what he wants to do in life.Cider House Rules The Cider House Rules, begins in the s in St.
Cloud's orphanage in Maine where Homer Wells is born and spends most of his teenage years. Three times he is adopted by good families, but later returned to the orphanage. In THE CIDER HOUSE RULES, Irving again tackles a central issue of the women’s movement--abortion--treating it with great sensitivity and insight.
Cider House Rules The Cider House Rules, begins in the s in St.
Cloud's orphanage in Maine where Homer Wells is born and spends most of his teenage years. Three times he is adopted by good families, but later returned to the orphanage.
The Cider House Rules The movie, The Cider House Rules, contains many different themes and elements that could have been interpreted several different ways depending on the person and their distinct preference.
The Cider House Rules" is a movie based on John Irving's best selling book. It is a very wonderful, touching, and real ¡¦s life story.
The story centered on an orphanage child named Homer and a sick doctor, Dr Larch who will have an emotional bond with Homer. Cider House Rules Essay Words | 3 Pages. The Cider House Rules" is a movie based on John Irving's best selling book.
It is a very wonderful, touching, and real ¡¦s life story.