An analysis of the link between violence in television causing real life violence

This article was published more than one year ago.

An analysis of the link between violence in television causing real life violence

One problem with meta-analysis is that if studies of questionable quality are included, the overall effect size obtained will be of questionable accuracy.

An analysis of the link between violence in television causing real life violence

To avoid this problem, two approaches are used. One is to define quality requirements for the inclusion of a study. Nonetheless, that meta-analysis showed that even including all relevant studies resulted in significant effects.

Processes Linking Media Violence Exposure to Aggressive Behavior There are multiple theoretical explanations for the link between media violence and aggressive behavior.

The GAM describes short-term as well as long-term processes. The short-term processes see Figure 1 are described as an episodic and cyclical pattern, where situational e. This present internal state is characterized by three main types of variables: Any input variable can affect any and all of the three present internal state variables.

For example, a homicide shown on television can lead to aggressive cognitions, increased physiological arousal, and feelings of anger or hostility. The three present internal state variables also influence each other.

For example, the feeling of hostility is likely to increase arousal. Increases in aggressive cognition, aggressive affect, and arousal all increase the likelihood of aggressive behavior. This aggressive behavior then influences the situation and the cycle starts over again.

Adapted from Anderson and Bushman, a. The effect of violent media is not limited to short-term effects; there is also a range of long-term processes linking media violence to aggressive behavior. In other words, people learn.

Individuals then apply these concepts outside of the media context. The acquired concepts as well as the basic processes will be presented in the next sections. These scripts consist of distinct, simple actions as well as normative beliefs, which contain the information about when the execution of the scripts is acceptable.

Media often portray violence as rewarding and acceptable behavior. Consuming violent media therefore leads individuals to be more accepting in their beliefs regarding the execution of aggressive scripts. Longitudinal studies have shown that the normative beliefs act as a mediator between exposure to media violence and aggressive behavior, supporting script theory.But research is clearly lacking on a direct causal relationship between violent video games and youth violence.

Analyses of school shooting incidents from the U.S. Secret Service and the Federal Bureau of Investigation National Center for the Analysis of Violent Crime do not support a link between violent games and real world attacks. In his other study, Ferguson looked for signs of links between violence in video games and real-life violence among American young people from to Violence in video games rose steadily, while it fell among young people in real life, he found.

A recent longitudinal study of my own, following to year-old boys and girls over a three-year period, now in press with Journal of Psychiatric Research, finds no long-term link between violent video games and youth aggression or dating violence.". Virtually since the dawn of television, parents, teachers, legislators and mental health professionals have wanted to understand the impact of television programs, particularly on children.

Of special concern has been the portrayal of violence, particularly given psychologist Albert Bandura's work. The relationship between violent media and real-world violence has been the subject of extensive “The Contested Field of Violent Video Games,” gives an overview of recent scholarship on video games and societal violence, including ones that support a link and others Journalist’s Resource is an open-access site that curates.

In contrast, a longitudinal study published this year by Ferguson and colleagues, 7 which followed boys and girls (aged 10 to 14 years) over 3 years, found no long-term link between violent video games and youth aggression or dating violence.

Violence, Media Effects, and Criminology - Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Criminology